Well, it's official--I'm a cuckold.
When she got home (around 1) she woke me up and kissed me; I could taste his cum in her mouth. She said she'd give me all the details in the morning.
He was already at the bar when she arrived. She said she was so nervous when she got there. He told her she looked really hot, which she claims made her blush.
The two of them made small talk and drank. He had a few beers and Catherine had cubis (rum, coke, with a slice of lime). They took his car back to his place. In the car, his exact words to her were, "I'm so damn hard for you right now."
She did what I had suggested earlier that evening before she left for the date. She slid her hand between his legs and stroked him. She thought that that surprised him a little. She continued to stroke him until they arrived at his house.
When they got to his house he immediately led my wife to the bedroom. Apparently he had mentioned back at the bar that he gives really good back rubs. When they got to his room, he took off his pants and shirt, but left on his boxers. He took off Catherine's sweater and shirt, then stood behind her and took off her bra. He was kissing her back and the back of her neck and was fondling her tits, playing with the nipples. He was close enough to her that she rubbed her ass against him. He was definitely hard.
She undid her own belt, but he finished undressing her, from behind.
Troy didn't even really see her panties, because her jeans and panties came off together and were tossed. (We'd spent some time picking out just the right pair of panties, too--a white thong).
He had Catherine lay on her stomach on his bed and he straddled her and put lotion on her back and gave her a massage, which really turned her on. When he asked if anything else needed to be rubbed she replied, " My ass."
He moved further down so that he was sitting on her legs and started rubbing her ass in circles and every once in awhile, the movements would spread her ass cheeks. That seems to have excited her a lot.
He did that for a little while, then he moved his right leg between her legs and spread them. She felt his fingers moving over her clit and pussy lips.
When he started fingering her she said it felt really good and that she was so wet. His thumb was near her asshole, and although he didn't penetrate she said that just having it so close was a turn on. She couldn't help but to start moaning. He flipped her over on her back, slid his fingers back inside her and started eating her out. Troy especially appreciated the fact that my wife keeps her pussy shaved smooth. He finger fucked her and licked her pussy and sucked on her clit until she came. At one point, she asked him if he liked the taste of her cunt. He said something like 'fuck, it's tasty'. She came really loudly.
All this time Troy still had his boxers on and she hadn't even seen his dick yet, just felt it through his jeans in the car and then through his boxers when she rubbed back against him.
She sat up and pushed him down and pulled his boxers off him.
He was quite hard, about seven inches, and cut. She got between his legs and started by licking his balls. He must've really liked that because Catherine said he was moaning just at that.
She teased a little by licking his cock before taking him into her mouth.
She paid a lot of attention to just the head of his cock before taking more of him into her mouth. He had to hold her hair so that he could watch.
She ended up sucking him off until he came in her mouth. She swallowed about half of it and smeared the rest of it on his dick with her tongue and then licked it up. I asked her if he'd warned her before he came and she said he told her he was going to cum and she sucked harder while also lightly rubbing his balls while she was sucking.
After that, They went out into the living room, had some takes and had idle chit chat for about half an hour or so before he had his hand between her legs again while they were on the couch. She pulled his dick out of his shorts and sucked his cock again for a little bit while he fingered her.
Troy had told her that when he was giving her a back rub, he was so turned on by her ass that he wanted to fuck her doggy-style so he could watch it. She told him that he had to use a condom and he said of course. Catherine said that his dick felt so good inside her that she almost came right away. Feeling it stroking her insides and imagining that I was there watching made her cum fast and loudly.
After she came, Troy started fucking her faster and harder. She had to hold on to the end of the couch so her head wouldn't hit into it.
After about 10 minutes of fucking (still in doggy style), She came again. When she told him that she was going to cum again he said he was too. So she explained to me that he did cum inside her, even though he was wearing a condom. (She knows I fantasize about eating her creampies). She said the sex was fantastic and that she and Troy will probably hook up again soon.
The entire time she was telling me this she was stroking my cock. Just hearing about her finally fucking another guy made me cum really quickly.